Transgender Volleyball Player Continues to Break Women’s Records
Transgender athlete Blaire Fleming has been making headlines at San Jose State University (SJSU) for breaking women’s volleyball records, despite ongoing controversy and boycotts by several opposing teams. On Saturday, Fleming reached his 250th kill shot during a match against San Diego State, marking another milestone in his record-breaking career. This achievement comes just one year after Fleming first hit the 250 mark in 2022, during his initial season with the team.
Fleming’s continued success on the court is significant, particularly as SJSU has faced disruptions from opposing teams who have chosen to forfeit rather than compete against Fleming. This season, five teams—Nevada, Utah, Boise State, Wyoming, and Utah State—have opted not to play SJSU, citing concerns over Fleming’s physical advantage and the perceived unfairness of his participation in women’s sports. Some teams have also expressed safety concerns due to Fleming’s strength, which they argue gives him a competitive edge over female athletes.
The situation has sparked debate within the sports community, as well as controversy at SJSU. The university has faced criticism for its decision to allow Fleming to play on the women’s team, with some alleging that the policy is unfair to female athletes. The tension surrounding Fleming’s participation led to the suspension of assistant coach Melissa Batie-Smoose earlier this month. Batie-Smoose had publicly opposed the school’s trans-inclusion policy, filing a Title IX complaint and giving an interview in which she criticized the culture created by the policy. She argued that the school’s approach had fostered a toxic environment for both players and coaches.
In her Title IX complaint, Batie-Smoose made allegations of misconduct involving Fleming and another teammate, claiming they had conspired to lose a match and potentially harm another player, Brooke Slusser. Slusser, who is a part of a Title IX lawsuit against the NCAA, accuses SJSU of covering up the fact that Fleming was born male. According to Batie-Smoose, Fleming and a teammate violated team rules by leaving their hotel on October 3 to meet with a player from Colorado State, where they allegedly discussed strategies to help Colorado State win and agreed that Fleming would not block any shots directed at Slusser.
Batie-Smoose’s allegations have added fuel to the ongoing controversy, which has also led to legal challenges against the NCAA. Several groups have filed lawsuits against the organization, arguing that allowing transgender women to compete in women’s sports is unfair to female athletes and violates Title IX protections.
SJSU has declined to provide further details on the suspension of Batie-Smoose, stating that she is “not with the team at this time” but offering no additional comment. The university has faced mounting pressure from various quarters as the debate over transgender athletes in women’s sports continues to intensify.
Photo credit: Flickr










